Affordable Gen4 Speed for Budget-Conscious Users, but with Notable Trade-offs
The Crucial P3 Plus Gen4 NVMe SSD offers Gen4 speeds at a budget-friendly price, making it an attractive choice for users looking to upgrade their storage without breaking the bank, but it comes with some significant compromises in performance and features that are worth considering.
Design and Build Quality
The Crucial P3 Plus features a simple, no-frills design with
no additional heat spreaders or fancy aesthetics, keeping costs low but leaving
it at a disadvantage compared to more premium SSDs like the Samsung 980 Pro,
which includes a built-in heat sink for better thermal performance.
While the design is minimalistic, this choice could lead to
overheating issues under heavy workloads, especially in systems with poor
airflow.
Performance and Speed
When it comes to speed, the Crucial P3 Plus boasts
advertised sequential read speeds of up to 5,000 MB/s and write speeds of 3,600
MB/s, taking advantage of PCIe Gen4 technology.
In practice, though, the performance falls short of
expectations, especially when compared to other Gen4 drives like the WD Black
SN770, which offers faster speeds and better sustained performance in
high-demand tasks.
While the P3 Plus is faster than Gen3 SSDs like the Kingston
NV2, it underperforms for a Gen4 drive, particularly in extended,
high-intensity operations like 4K video editing or large file transfers.
Real-World Use Case
In real-world testing, the Crucial P3 Plus handled
day-to-day tasks like booting Windows, launching applications, and transferring
smaller files with ease, offering a noticeable improvement over Gen3 SSDs.
However, it struggled during prolonged heavy workloads,
showing signs of performance degradation when dealing with larger file
transfers or sustained data writes.
Compared to the Samsung 970 EVO Plus, which provides better
endurance and consistency, the P3 Plus falls behind, making it less suitable
for power users working with extensive media files or large databases.
Thermal Performance
A key issue with the Crucial P3 Plus is its thermal
management, or rather, the lack of it.
Without a heat sink or adequate thermal control, the drive
tends to heat up significantly under heavy load, which can lead to thermal
throttling and reduced performance over time.
In comparison, the Seagate FireCuda 530, with its advanced
heat management, performs far better in extended sessions, particularly in
gaming or rendering scenarios.
Users in warmer environments or those with compact systems
might experience performance dips during intense tasks due to heat buildup.
Durability and Endurance
With a Total Bytes Written (TBW) rating of 220TB, the
Crucial P3 Plus is on the lower end of endurance ratings, especially when
compared to higher-end competitors like the Kingston KC3000, which boasts
nearly double the endurance for a 1TB drive.
This low TBW rating makes the P3 Plus less appealing for
users who require a drive for heavy use over the long term, such as video
editors or developers working with large datasets.
The drive is adequate for general consumer usage, but
professionals might want to look elsewhere.
Installation and Compatibility
Installing the Crucial P3 Plus was straightforward, and it
performed well across a variety of motherboards supporting PCIe Gen4 and Gen3
slots.
However, users with PCIe Gen3 systems won't be able to take
full advantage of its Gen4 speeds, and if you're not planning to upgrade your
system soon, the Gen3-only P3 (non-Plus) might offer better value.
Compared to alternatives like the Corsair MP600, which also
features Gen4 compatibility, the Crucial P3 Plus provides a budget-friendly
option but falls short in maximizing Gen4's full potential.
Gaming Performance
In terms of gaming, the Crucial P3 Plus delivered adequate
performance for loading times and general gameplay in most modern titles, but
it didn’t outperform other Gen4 drives like the WD Black SN850 in
speed-critical situations such as open-world games where constant data
streaming is required.
Games like Red Dead Redemption 2 and Cyberpunk
2077 loaded relatively fast, but the overall in-game experience could
benefit from the higher speeds of a faster Gen4 SSD.
Price-to-Performance Ratio
Where the Crucial P3 Plus truly shines is its
price-to-performance ratio, making it one of the more affordable Gen4 NVMe SSDs
available.
For users on a budget who want a faster SSD than what Gen3
options provide, it’s hard to beat the value proposition of the P3 Plus.
That being said, other budget-friendly Gen4 options like the
Sabrent Rocket 4.0 offer better performance at a slightly higher price point,
which could be worth the extra investment for users who need more sustained
speed.
Downsides for Power Users
For power users, the Crucial P3 Plus lacks the features and
performance required for intensive tasks.
The absence of DRAM, which is present in more premium models
like the Samsung 980 Pro, impacts its ability to maintain high speeds during
sustained write tasks, making it less ideal for creative professionals or heavy
gamers.
The performance dips under pressure and thermal limitations
also make it a less reliable choice for users with more demanding storage
needs.
Conclusion
The Crucial P3 Plus 1TB Gen4 NVMe is a solid choice for
budget-conscious users looking to dip into Gen4 speeds, but it comes with
limitations that make it less appealing for more demanding users.
Its performance is acceptable for everyday tasks and
moderate workloads, but it struggles in scenarios where sustained high
performance and thermal control are critical.
Pros:
- Affordable
Gen4 option
- Easy
to install and widely compatible
- Solid
performance for everyday tasks
Cons:
- Lacks
DRAM, impacting sustained write performance
- Thermal
throttling under heavy workloads
- Low
TBW rating, limiting endurance for power users
For users looking for better sustained performance and
endurance at a slightly higher price, the WD Black SN770 or Sabrent
Rocket 4.0 would be a better alternative, offering better overall value for
more demanding use cases.
[affiliate name="Western Digital WD_BLACK 1TB SN770 NVMe Internal Gaming SSD Solid State Drive - Gen4 PCIe, M.2 2280, Up to 5,150 MB/s - WDS100T3X0E" url="https://amzn.to/3Y63fcs" discounted_price="72.99" discount="34" img="https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/71Sr1zjPhwL._AC_SX466_.jpg"]
[affiliate name="SABRENT 1TB Rocket 4 Plus NVMe 4.0 Gen4 PCIe M.2 Internal SSD Extreme Performance Solid State Drive (Latest Version) (SB-RKT4P-1TB)" url="https://amzn.to/4harfUy" discounted_price="119.99" discount="1" img="https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/71Saa1z5N5L._AC_SX466_.jpg"]
Post a Comment